The government is taking a closer look at scans because imaging tests are among the fastest growing procedures in health care. Medicare’s Hospital Compare Web site publishes individual hospital rates of double chest scans, along with rates for several other kinds of imaging. Medicare doesn’t restrict the use of double scans or penalize those who perform lots of them.
“Just making the information public is a fairly strong incentive” for hospitals to examine their rates, says Michael Rapp, director of quality measurement at the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Nationwide, hospitals performed double scans on 5.4 percent of Medicare patients who received chest CTs in emergency rooms or hospital radiology units where they were referred by their doctors. Those scans totaled 76,781 in 2008. The overall number was certainly higher, as patients with private insurance, Medicaid or no coverage also get double scans, but no one tracks the number.
Experts say almost all chest problems can be properly diagnosed with a single scan. But some physicians who order the tests still value double scans for gathering the most information possible. Hospitals and radiologists are paid more for the double scans, so they have a disincentive to crack down on them.
“This is one of thousands of things we do every day in health care that cause more harm than good,” says Rosemary Gibson, co-author of “The Treatment Trap” and editor of a series of articles on overtreatment in the Archives of Internal Medicine.
Most hospitals used the double chest scans sparingly. The median rate was 2 percent of all Medicare patients who received chest scans, according to Hospital Compare data on 3,094 hospitals. But 618 hospitals performed the tests on at least 10 percent of Medicare patients getting a chest CT scan.
Ninety-four of those hospitals performed double scans on at least half their patients getting chest scans. The highest rates “really raise a red flag,” says Paul L. Molina, chief of chest imaging at the University of North Carolina School of Medicine.
While some hospitals are trying to discourage doctors from habitually ordering the tests, others say it’s beyond their control because they don’t usually employ the physicians. Michael Thompson, a Providence spokesman, said in an e-mail that “the decision for the ordering or appropriateness of testing is determined by the ordering physician and not the hospital.”
Outside of examining plaque in the arteries or checking for a tear or leak in the aorta — the major artery carrying blood out of the heart — there are few reasons to do a double scan, according to guidelines developed by the American College of Radiology.